Mafia II: Definitive Edition Walkthrough Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law: West Side Mall Heist

Escaping the West Side Mall After the Carat Cerny Heist in Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law

In this episode

Quests
Murphy’s Law
Locations
Joe’s Apartment, Freddy’s Bar, West Side Mall, Carat Cerny
NPCs
Vito Scaletta, Joe Barbaro, Henry Tomasino, Brian O’Neill, Alberto Clemente, O’Neill Gang, Empire Bay Police Department
Unlocks
Night Shift

Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law sends Vito Scaletta and Joe Barbaro into the West Side Mall for a quiet jewelry job that does not stay quiet. After the gas-stamp work in Chapter 3: Enemy of the State, Joe leaves a note at the apartment and points us at Freddy’s Bar, where Henry Tomasino wants payment collected in jewels.

The plan is lockpicks, phone-company coveralls, and an empty store after dark. What we get is Brian O’Neill driving a van through the window of Carat Cerny, the Empire Bay Police Department rolling on the mall, and a rooftop run that ends with the Irish pinched in the alley while we still have to get home.

Vito Scaletta with Joe's note

Joe’s Note and the Briefing at Freddy’s Bar

The chapter opens on Joe’s note. He can barely write, but the ask is clear: another job, something big, Freddy’s Bar tonight, a piece and lockpicks. We are downstairs in the booth before the coffee even lands. Joe needles us for sleeping in after the last score, and we take it, because the Office of Price Administration night did run long.

A man at the next table finishes a hard call about money owed to Alberto Clemente and tells Henry Tomasino to collect it now. Joe asks who that was. Henry keeps the name off the table and puts the work on it instead. A debtor borrowed from the boss to open a jewelry store and is not paying fast enough, so we take the payment tonight in jewels, plus a little extra. Joe fills in the rest: the store is in the shopping mall in the middle of town, no guards after dark, pick the lock and walk in.

It sounds thin. Joe already has phone-company uniforms so we can look like a night repair if anyone sees the door. We wait until dark and go pick them up.

Henry Tomasino with Joe Barbaro at Freddy's

Coveralls and the Talk About Derek

On the ride after the uniforms, Joe asks how the port went. We tell him Derek Pappalardo is the same piece of work who shakes down dock workers the way he shook down our old man, and that the work he gave us was small-time. Joe does not want the complaint. He says to stay in touch with Derek, because the man has better jobs than leaning on wharf rats.

The mall is still ahead of us. The coveralls are on, the lockpicks are in the pocket, and the store Henry pointed at is supposed to be empty.

Joe Barbaro in the phone company uniform

Breaking Into Carat Cerny

We take the West Side Mall marker and work the lock on Carat Cerny. For a minute the plan is still the one Joe sold upstairs: no guards, cases open, jewels in the bag. That minute ends when a van comes through the front window.

Carat Cerny after the van hits

Brian O’Neill Wants the Same Store

Brian O’Neill and his crew pile out to rob Carat Cerny themselves. He knows Joe on sight and wants everything we already pulled. Joe tells him he is late and that the sign outside did not have O’Neill’s name on it. If it had, Joe says, he would have burned the place instead of cracking it.

Police radio cuts in with a burglary at the West Side Mall. O’Neill still wants the take more than he wants a clean exit. We are done talking. Joe wants the door, and we have to move before the first cruisers pin the store.

Brian O'Neill in Carat Cerny

Locked Doors and the Icy Roof

Joe works the first interior door while we cover him, then calls us through and puts the roof on the route. The next doors are dead ends or locked. He picks while we hold the stairs, and the O’Neill Gang and the Empire Bay Police Department both feed the same halls.

On the roof the ledge is ice. Joe wants us across anyway. He is not going to the joint for a jewelry bag, and standing still on that roof is how the cops get both of us. We cross, take fire from the next landing, and cut toward a stair that Joe thinks will drop us on the street. They are still coming when we hit the fire escape.

Vito Scaletta on the icy mall roof

The Pinch, the Bag, and the Clothing Store

In the alley Joe watches the police put hands on the Irish and names the man in the wagon: Brian O’Neill, all hired muscle and no brains. Henry, he says, is never going to believe the night. Then he takes our bag to ditch the goods and tells us to meet him back at the apartment without getting pinched on the way.

The radio already has a suspect: about six feet, dark hair, medium build. We steal a car, get out of the light, and stop at a clothing store long enough for the clerk to sell us a change. The coveralls come off. That should have killed the wanted face. It does not kill the rest of the drive. We still have to shake a last bit of heat before Joe’s Apartment and the couch. Sleeping it off closes Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law and unlocks Night Shift. Next out of Freddy’s Bar is Chapter 5: The Buzzsaw.

O'Neill Gang in the alley with police

Mafia II Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law Lore Facts

The title is the old warning

Murphy’s Law is the fourth chapter in Mafia II, dated February 11th, 1945. The name is the adage that anything that can go wrong will go wrong, which is the whole shape of the Carat Cerny job once Brian O’Neill’s van hits the window.

Carat Cerny is a developer nod

The jewelry store inside the West Side Mall is named Carat Cerny. The name points at Denis Černý, credited as LS3D Engine Director on the original Mafia. This chapter is the only time we walk the interior.

First look at Brian O’Neill

Brian O’Neill leads the O’Neill Gang and first shows up here, crashing the same collection Henry Tomasino sent us to make for Alberto Clemente. Joe tags him in the alley as hired muscle. The Empire Bay Police Department takes him in before we change clothes and go home.

Mafia II Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law FAQ

What happens in Mafia II Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law?

Vito Scaletta and Joe Barbaro rob Carat Cerny at the West Side Mall after Henry Tomasino sends them to collect a jewelry-store debt for Alberto Clemente. Brian O’Neill hits the same store, the police arrive, and the chapter becomes a mall-and-rooftop escape that ends at Joe’s Apartment.

How do you get out of the West Side Mall?

Follow Joe and cover him on the locks. He calls the roof after the first doors, then takes an icy ledge to the next building because the street exits are already dead. The fire escape drops us in the alley where the police are cuffing the O’Neill Gang.

Why won’t the rooftop ledge open in Murphy’s Law?

A cop is usually still standing in the hall or stairwell behind the roof door. The ledge does not become usable until those officers are down. In Mafia II: Definitive Edition they sometimes idle instead of rushing out, so we have to walk back to that door and clear the hall before Joe will take the crossing.

How do you lose the wanted level after the jewelry heist?

Joe takes the bag and leaves us wanted in the alley. In this run we steal a car, get out of the light, and buy a change at a clothing store so the coveralls are gone. The chapter still only ends when we reach Joe’s Apartment and sleep.

What does the Night Shift achievement unlock?

Night Shift unlocks for finishing Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law. It pops when we return to Joe’s Apartment and use the couch after the West Side Mall escape. It is story progress, not a separate challenge.