Mafia II: Definitive Edition Walkthrough Chapter 5: The Buzzsaw

Hitting Sidney Pen at the Sand Island Distillery in Chapter 5: The Buzzsaw

In this episode

Quests
The Buzzsaw
Locations
Joe’s Apartment, Freddy’s Bar, Harry’s Gun Shop (Kingston), Apartment 233 in Sand Island, Sidney Pen’s Distillery, El Greco’s House (Highbrook), Scaletta Family Apartment
NPCs
Vito Scaletta, Joe Barbaro, Henry Tomasino, Luca Gurino, Alberto Clemente, Harry Marsden, Sidney Pen, El Greco, Francesca Scaletta
Unlocks
A Lesson in Manners

Chapter 5: The Buzzsaw is Vito Scaletta’s first real hit for the Clemente family. After the jewelry job in Chapter 4: Murphy’s Law, Luca Gurino wants to know if Vito and Joe Barbaro can take a man out just because someone points a finger, and the answer is supposed to be waiting across the river at Sidney Pen’s distillery in Sand Island.

We pick up an MG-42 from Harry’s Gun Shop in Kingston, sit on apartment 233 until Pen’s cars roll in, and then chase him through a building that starts to burn. Henry Tomasino takes a bullet on the top floor, and the rest of the chapter is a timed run to El Greco in Highbrook and a stop at Francesca with the two thousand dollars that covers Papa’s debt.

Vito Scaletta with Joe's girl at the apartment

Joe’s Apartment and the Fight in the Street

We wake in Joe’s place on February 20th, 1945, and Joe’s girl is already on her way out. Joe is not home. She tells us to meet him for lunch at Freddy’s, then she is gone, and we dress and head for the street.

Outside the building one of Joe’s girls has just been rear-ended, and the other driver is already on her about the car. We step in and tell him to leave her alone. He wants someone to pay for the damage, keeps talking, and the argument turns into a fist fight in the street. When he is down she thanks us, offers pie at her place, and we turn it down because Freddy’s is waiting.

Vito Scaletta with Joe's girl in the street

Lunch at Freddy’s with Luca Gurino

Joe and Henry Tomasino are already in the booth when we walk into Freddy’s, and they introduce Luca Gurino. Luca has heard about the work with the mixed crew and wants to know if we are ready for the next step: taking somebody out because a man points a finger and says the name. We tell him we spent the war killing the people the president pointed at. Luca likes the line, then makes the real point. He is not talking about enemy soldiers. He is talking about whoever the family names.

Handle this job the way we handled the last one, he says, and there is a good chance we get accepted into the family after we pay the initiation fee. Five grand apiece. Joe calls it a fortune. Luca leaves the choice with us and says Henry will fill in the rest. Before he can walk, Don Alberto Clemente comes through the room, asks Luca if that other thing is handled, and takes him aside when the answer is not good enough.

Henry’s contract is a fat man from across the river who has already been warned and still thinks he is untouchable. Someone tried him once and died for the mistake. Henry has rented an apartment across from the man’s business. We sit there until the target shows, then we cut him down with an MG-42. The gun is waiting at Harry’s shop in Kingston, paid for, no license needed. Joe and Henry go set the room. We pick up the hardware and meet them at apartment 233 in Sand Island, the building across from the distillery.

Luca Gurino with Vito Scaletta at Freddy's

Harry’s Gun Shop and the MG-42

Kingston puts us at Harry’s door with Henry’s name. Harry Marsden buzzes us in, looks us over, and brings out the piece Henry ordered: an MG-42 out of Germany. He calls it Hitler’s buzzsaw, twenty-five pounds, 7.92, twelve hundred rounds a minute, a two-hundred-fifty-round belt, and three-quarters of a mile of effective range. Unless the thing we are hunting lives in a tank, he says, it will not last.

He offers to show us how to run it. We already know. We were in the service too, Africa rather than his Normandy, and the talk turns to Operation Husky, the 504th, a Purple Heart, and a Distinguished Service Cross. Harry lost the eye on a tree branch coming back from Utah Beach and still got the discharge. The gun is in the crate. A couple thousand rounds sit in the van out in the yard, already paid for. We take the van and leave the car we arrived in.

Harry Marsden with the MG-42 in Kingston

The Ambush from Apartment 233

Apartment 233 looks over the distillery in Sand Island. Joe is half-asleep at the table while Henry talks. He is from Sicily. Mussolini made the old country dangerous for a man of honor, so Henry’s father sent him to America and got him work with Clemente rather than watch him get drafted or locked up. The father was too old to make the trip himself. Mussolini had him arrested, he died in jail, and they would not even turn the body over for a burial.

The wait breaks when the black cars come down the street. Henry wants the fat man tagged before he reaches the building. We put the MG-42 on the window and open up on the convoy. The men in the street go down and the cars cook, but Pen still makes the door. The window job is over in a burst. Joe and Henry are already moving for the stairs, and we drop the buzzsaw and follow them toward the distillery.

Vito Scaletta with the MG-42 in Sand Island

Through Sidney Pen’s Distillery

The street in front of the building is still live when we hit it. Joe wants backup, Henry wants us moving before the fat man disappears upstairs, and the three of us kick the distillery open and fight the first floor room by room. Pen’s crew is dug in behind crates and counters, and the place starts to smell like a fire long before we see the flames.

We push the second floor, ride the elevator when Joe hits the button, and listen to him help himself to a bottle on the way up. Reinforcements come with the lift and more guns wait on the upper floors. Henry keeps calling the target Porky and pointing us higher. The building is already coming apart when we reach the last landing, and the only way out of the job is through the man who owns it.

Joe Barbaro with Henry Tomasino in the distillery

Sidney Pen and the Shot That Hits Henry

We corner Sidney Pen on the top floor. He begs. He has a wife. Henry tells him he should have thought about her sooner and puts Clemente’s name on the job. Pen still has a gun. He puts a round into Henry and the room turns. Joe and Vito empty what they are holding into him until he is down, and then the only problem left in the building is the hole in Henry’s leg.

Henry is not okay, and he is not quiet about it. He wants El Greco, and he has to say doctor when Joe hears painter. The Greek lives up in Highbrook. We get Henry on his feet while the distillery starts to burn around the barrels, and Joe takes the weight because Henry cannot walk the stairs on his own. Pen is finished. The chapter is not.

Sidney Pen in the Sand Island distillery

El Greco in Highbrook and Francesca’s Debt

The way down is fire and leftover guns. Henry calls the whole job a jinx and still tells us to keep moving. Outside we load him into the car with Joe in the back and drive for Highbrook with a clock on the dash and police behind the hit. Henry talks like a man who has seen this scene in a movie, Joe tells him not to say the line about not making it, and the hole in his leg is the size of a golf ball by the time we are on the bridge.

Joe explains El Greco on the ride. Throw him a couple of bucks and he patches you up with no questions, which is the point, because a hospital sees a bullet and calls the cops. We stop in front of the Highbrook house. El Greco comes to the door, makes the painter joke, and takes Henry inside. Joe stays with him. Henry still finds the two thousand for us before we leave.

That is the number Francesca needs for Papa’s debt. We take it to the Scaletta apartment and put it in her hands. She was ready to talk installments. She wants to know where the money came from and whether we have done something we will be sorry for. We tell her everything is fine, ask her to keep Ma from seeing us, and leave her to invent the story.

El Greco at his house in Highbrook

Mafia II Chapter 5: The Buzzsaw Lore Facts

The chapter is named for the gun

Harry Marsden calls the MG-42 Hitler’s buzzsaw when he hands it over in Kingston, and that nickname is the chapter title. In the shop he walks Vito through the weight, the caliber, the rate of fire, and the belt, then sends us out with the crate and the van already paid for by Henry.

Sidney Pen already beat one hit

Henry’s briefing at Freddy’s never uses the civilian name. He calls the mark a fat man from across the river who has been warned and still thinks he is untouchable. A earlier crew tried him and died. The official name is Sidney Pen, a former Clemente associate who opened the Sand Island distillery and stopped paying the family.

Henry’s father never left Sicily

While we wait in apartment 233, Henry tells Vito why he is in Empire Bay. Mussolini made Sicily dangerous for a man of honor, so Silvio Tomasino sent his son to America and into Clemente’s orbit. Silvio was too old for the crossing. He was arrested, died in jail, and the body was never released for a burial.

El Greco is the doctor, not the painter

Henry’s first instruction after the shooting is El Greco. Joe hears painter. The man who opens the Highbrook door is Andreas Karafantis, the underworld doctor who will take a bullet case for cash and keep the police out of it. The painter line is the same joke he uses when Vito asks if he has the right house.

Mafia II Chapter 5: The Buzzsaw FAQ

Who is Sidney Pen in Mafia 2 Chapter 5?

Sidney Pen is the fat man Henry Tomasino is contracted to kill, the owner of the Sand Island distillery across from apartment 233. In the chapter he is Porky and the fat bastard more often than he is Sidney. He makes it inside after the MG-42 ambush, shoots Henry on the top floor, and dies there when Vito and Joe finish the job.

Where is Harry’s Gun Shop in The Buzzsaw?

Harry’s Gun Shop is in Kingston, marked after the meeting at Freddy’s. Henry sends Vito there for the MG-42 and tells him to use his name at the door. The shop sits under an Army Navy front. Harry hands over the paid-for crate and points us to the van in the yard for the ammunition.

How do you get the MG-42 in Chapter 5?

Henry already paid for it. After Luca leaves Freddy’s, drive to Harry’s in Kingston, tell Harry that Henry Tomasino sent you, and take the crate he brings out. Load it into the van waiting in the yard and drive that van to apartment 233 in Sand Island. The window gun in the ambush is that same MG-42.

Where do you take Henry after he gets shot?

El Greco’s house in Highbrook. Henry asks for him by name the moment he is hit, Joe rides in the back with him, and Vito drives with a timer running and police off the distillery fire. El Greco takes Henry at the door. Joe stays. Henry still pays Vito two thousand dollars before we leave for Francesca.

How do you unlock A Lesson in Manners?

It fires from the street fight outside Joe’s apartment at the start of the chapter. Joe’s girl gets rear-ended, the other driver goes after her, and Vito steps in. Finish the fist fight and the lesson is over. The rest of The Buzzsaw is the hit, not that trophy.